Alba tag

[.Phoenix]

Hi

[Blink]

I've looked at this thread a few times trying to decide my opinion on these.

The render and stock blending is fine. But I really don't like how it came out. She looks like just a head or something, I dunno but to me its sorta weird.

The color one is better too btw. Also, why did you add the dark bar at the side? Is that for text, and if so why didn't you add it? Needs some text because it's looking a little bland.

Rate: 6/10

[Nick]

I like the colors and c4ds but i just dont think the blending is good.
remove the border too.

[Soul Glow Activature]

i like th coloerd one alot more, and the c4d's look great, but i think that background is a little to plain compared to the rest of the sig.

6/10

[Stinky666]

You've got the flow effects going in a couple of different directions, and that ruins it. You need to pick one direction for it to flow in, so it will flow better. With that stock you could have chose a few different directions for flow. xD

[Vertigo]

Eh, it's ok but not great. I love the colours and the blending on the stock. The C4D work/brushing looks good too. As for the negative side, there's a bit too much passive space. You could use some of that space for something else like some text which is another thing that might be nice. Don't get me wrong, I like that you have space that space. It looks less cluttered than most sigs. The border is a bit much. Sometimes a thick border can be nice but I don't like that 2px of white. I think a simple 1px black border would look better in this case, but that's just me.

Oh, and as for the black and white one I don't like it at all. Black and white can be good if you adjust your levels and such. Still it doesn't go with the style of the siggy.
_______________

stinky666 said:

You've got the flow effects going in a couple of different directions, and that ruins it. You need to pick one direction for it to flow in, so it will flow better. With that stock you could have chose a few different directions for flow. xD

I would have to disagree with you here. The flow is just fine. It draws your eye into the stock. Notice how much the renders and such point into the stock. There is a lot else going on as you said and you do have a point there, but it's not too bad.

[teg]

hi, awesome job. I'll post some of my work later, but you did a great job with this signature. I really like the colored one the best but the black/white one is good too...

so
1. Background - I really like the background you made for this signature. The colors are very nice together and I like the effects that went into it. I like the way you made them bright because it makes the background stand out.
2. The Image - Jessica is blend very well in the places she should be. I really like how her face in the image is full and not trying to blend with the background.

All in all this signature is a good one.